The Uprising In Iran | A Struggle Over Identity – This Is Why | USA TODAY

The Uprising in Iran is a Struggle Over Identity | This is Why, Originally published in USA Today | November 30, 2022, as well as in more than 100 newspapers (online & print) across North America.

On Sept. 16, Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old Iranian woman of Kurdish origin, died after her apparent torture and beating by Iranian morality police because she did not wear the veil covering her hair in accordance with the provisions of local law.

Her death shocked and disrupted Iranian society and the world at large. The Lebanese journalist Huda al-Husseini wrote, “In Iran, 83-year-old men kill 22-year-old young women. In Iran, the past kills the future.”

What some describe as a protest, others see as an uprising. Why is it important to distinguish between the two?

Iran is a country home to 86 million people. Its median age is 31, and about half of the country’s population is younger than 43 years old. These are people who were born into a life ruled by a theocratic, oppressive regime.

Every few years, “protests” break out, usually in attempts to bring about economic, political, and social reforms. Each time, the regime suppresses the protest with an iron fist. Thousands of Iranians are killed, and thousands more are carted away to languish and be tortured in prisons. Each time the protests fade, and no meaningful change is affected.

What is happening today in Iran is different. Instead of being another protest, it’s an uprising because it aims directly at the mullah regime’s ideological foundations and core values. As far as the regime is concerned, a red line has been crossed because the uprising encourages the open defiance of the cultural and social codes it imposes. Iranian women are burning the hijab, young Iranians are dancing and kissing in public, and these public displays of dissent aren’t about economic challenges, societal grievances, or political needs; they are about the core of the Iranian people’s identity.

Iran’s younger generation doesn’t see things the same way as their parents and definitely has a different perspective than the mullah regime. The two can’t coexist because their outlook, beliefs, and vision are at odds with each other. This is what led the younger generation to rise up — and together with increasingly expanding circles of the society — send a clear message: down with the oppression and down with the Mullah regime.

One noteworthy element of this uprising is the paradoxical position the West has taken. Western public opinion shows solidarity and support for the uprising in Iran. Yet, notably, some politicians, cultural icons and media associated with the democratic and progressive camp who historically have positioned themselves as the torchbearers of human rights, women’s rights, freedom, freedom of expression, etc., either remain silent or misattribute the uprising to economic and social hardships. Some justify their silence or evasive position by saying they fear their support for the uprising will be interpreted as “Islamophobia.” Yet, Iranian opposition activists and Arab commentators are taking note of their silence and evasiveness.

The Uprising in Iran is a Struggle Over Identity | This is Why, Originally published in USA Today | November 30, 2022, as well as in more than 100 newspapers (online & print) across North America.

That silence and evasiveness are not surprising. Because ironically, democratic and progressive elements are encouraging the conciliatory and appeasing policies towards the Mullah regime. That might be the biggest mistake Western governments and influencers are making — and they ought to refocus their efforts and recalibrate their compass. As former President Barack Obama admitted, the U.S. and the West were wrong when they turned their backs on the protest that broke out in Iran in 2009, which later became known as the “Green Revolution.”

Throughout history, there have been cases in which individuals create — either by accident or unintentionally — profound change on a massive scale. In December 2010, a young Tunisian peddler named Muhammad Bouazizi set himself on fire in an act of desperation and protest in the face of a grim reality and hopeless future. With this act, Bouazizi’s martyrdom led to perhaps one of the most defining events in Middle Eastern history — the “Arab Spring,” — which essentially became an ideological earthquake that reshaped the region.

At this stage, no one can fully predict the aftermath of the uprising in Iran. On the one hand, at this time, it does not seem that the uprising will result in the same mass demonstrations that in 1979 led to the fall of the Shah’s regime. On the other hand, what’s fueling the uprising, the struggle for a life of freedom, dignity, and progress, is inexhaustible.

No expert or pundit can fully ascertain whether Mahsa Amini’s death will cause a defining event on the scale of the “Arab Spring.” However, I think we can decisively say that after Mahsa Amini’s death, Iran won’t be the same as it was before September 2022.

The Uprising in Iran is a Struggle Over Identity | This is Why, Originally published in USA Today | November 30, 2022, as well as in more than 100 newspapers (online & print) across North America.

If you want to have a better understanding of the news and what really drives the unfolding events…
Read the latest book of Avi Melamed,

Follow me on Twitter @AviMelamed; Facebook @InsideTheMiddleEast; for more Videos on YouTube

I can always be reached at Av*@Av********.com

Avi Melamed
Avi Melamed
Avi Melamed is an expert on current affairs in the Arab & Muslim World and their impact on Israel & the Middle East. A former Israeli Intelligence Official & Senior Official on Arab Affairs, Fluent in Arabic, English, and Hebrew, he has held high-risk Government, Senior Advisory, Intelligence & Counter-Terrorist intelligence positions in Arab cities & communities - often in very sensitive times - on behalf of Israeli Government agencies. He is the Founder & CEO of Inside the Middle East | Intelligence Perspectives - an apolitical non-partisan curriculum using intelligence methodology to examine the Middle East. As an Author, Educator, Expert, and Strategic Intelligence Analyst, Avi provides Intelligence Analysis, Briefings, and Geopolitical Tours to diplomats, Israeli and foreign policymakers, global media outlets, and a wide variety of international businesses, organizations, and private clients on a range of Israel and Middle East Affairs.

JOIN THE HUB Newsletter


New book by Avi Melamed, acclaimed intelligence & geopolitical analyst - Inside the middle east | Entering a new era | published in 2022


Where is Egypt Heading?

Where is Egypt Heading? In November 2011 I published an article entitled “The Arab Awakening: An Era of New Slogans” in which I focused on...

Muqawama, Money, Missiles

Muqawama, Money, Missiles | The current round of violence between Israel and Hamas is caused by the simplest reason imaginable, yet very few are...

Avi Melamed’s Comments On The Anniversary Of The Abraham Accords | AL ARABIYA

Avi Melamed’s thoughts on the anniversary of the Abraham Accords that appeared in the Arabic Press. … Avi Melamed, a former Israeli intelligence official and...

Video of Exploding Barrels

Video of Exploding Barrels In the war in Syria Assad’s forces are indiscriminately shelling Syrian cities and towns.  Syrian civilians claim that helicopters of the...


The axis of resistance and defiance is a powerful web of Shi’ite and Sunni political and military —non-state, semi-state, and state entities—cultivated, developed, armed,...